The Pope questions the ‘authenticity’ of the pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela

by Lorraine Williamson
pilgrimage to Santiago de Compostela

The Camino de Santiago, one of the world’s most renowned pilgrimage routes, has become a global phenomenon. Each year, millions of people journey to Santiago de Compostela, drawn by the promise of spiritual fulfilment, personal reflection, or simply the adventure of the trail.

However, Pope Francis has invited reflection on the true nature of this pilgrimage, questioning whether it remains a spiritual experience or has become something else entirely.

From sacred journey to global attraction

Historically, the Camino de Santiago was a deeply religious pilgrimage, undertaken by devout Christians seeking penance, spiritual growth, or a connection to Saint James, whose remains are believed to rest in Santiago de Compostela’s cathedral. Over recent decades, however, its appeal has broadened. People of all faiths—and none—are drawn to the Camino for diverse reasons, including personal reflection, physical challenge, or cultural exploration.

Pilgrim offices in Santiago regularly report record-breaking participation. What was once a journey for a select few has evolved into a global phenomenon, attracting individuals of all ages and backgrounds. While this popularity is often celebrated, it has also prompted debate about the essence of the Camino.

Pope Francis: A call for reflection

During a special audience at the Vatican with Italian pilgrims of the Camino, Pope Francis spoke of the route’s significance and its evolving nature. He praised its widespread appeal, calling it “positive and interesting,” but questioned whether those walking the Camino are making a true pilgrimage.

“Do those who arrive in Santiago make a real pilgrimage?” the Pope asked. “Or is it something else? Of course, there are different experiences, but this issue invites us to reflect.”

The role of spiritual guidance

To preserve the Camino’s spiritual roots, Pope Francis highlighted the importance of providing guidance to those on the journey. He addressed a group of religious leaders, seminarians, and lay volunteers from Galicia, who have been offering spiritual support to pilgrims for over 15 years.

Describing their work as “living proof of Catholic commitment,” the Pope urged them to continue their evangelisation efforts. “Dear friends of the Camino de Santiago, I encourage you in this apostolate of evangelisation and care,” he said.

He also emphasised that true Christian pilgrimage should transform participants, inspiring them to return home as “apostles” of their faith.

The essential elements of a Christian pilgrimage

The Pope outlined three fundamental aspects that define a Christian pilgrimage:

  1. Silence: A space for reflection and connection with God.
  2. The Gospel: Daily reading of scripture to guide and inspire the journey.
  3. Service to others: A willingness to help and support fellow pilgrims and communities along the way.

“The journey becomes more authentic and Christian when it leads to self-abandonment and service to one’s neighbour,” Pope Francis said. “This is what the Holy Spirit does when we read the Gospel every day.”

Preserving the spirit of the Camino

As the Camino continues to attract record numbers, the challenge remains to balance its popularity with its spiritual roots. For some, the pilgrimage is a deeply transformative experience, while for others, it is an opportunity for adventure or self-discovery.

Pope Francis’s remarks invite reflection on what it means to undertake a pilgrimage in the modern age. Whether seeking faith, connection, or personal growth, his message underscores the importance of intention, humility, and service on the journey to Santiago de Compostela.

You may also like