Extravagant Christmas lights in Valencia have faced backlash as they stand in stark contrast to the devastation caused by the DANA recent floods.
With the memories of last month’s DANA disaster still fresh, Valencia switched on its annual Christmas lights this week. The festive displays have provoked anger among many, as residents in nearby areas are still struggling to recover from the impact of October’s severe rainfall. The city, however, appears to continue as though nothing has happened.
The local government insists the lighting event was held to honour the victims of the disaster. But many criticised the lavish decorations and the lack of a moment of silence before the ceremony. In the heavily impacted La Torre neighbourhood, locals said they were unaware of the festive occasion. In Castellar, where life is slowly getting back on track, residents called the lighting ceremony “inappropriate.”
Celebrations met with mixed reactions
Every year, Valencia celebrates the switch-on of its Christmas lights with fanfare, drawing large crowds. However, this year’s event has received a mixed response. The display comes as just kilometres away, people are still dealing with the fallout of the DANA storm on October 29, which claimed 16 lives in nearby regions.
The juxtaposition between festive cheer and recent tragedy has not been lost on many. The Christmas lights, while a sign of the season, seem out of place against the ongoing struggles of those dealing with the storm’s impact.
Christmas lights across Spain
The lighting of Christmas decorations marks the start of the festive season across Spain. Major cities like Malaga and Barcelona have similar events, attracting crowds and boosting business for local retailers. The spectacular city centre displays, often costing millions, are central to the pre-Christmas buzz and generate significant social media attention.
Valencia claims lights honour victims
The city government presented the Christmas lights as a tribute to DANA victims. But many took to social media to criticise the extravagance of the event, which featured fireworks. Questions were raised over whether the celebration was appropriate given recent events. Other public occasions, such as Constitution Day on December 6, were cancelled.
During the lighting ceremony, there was an attempt at reflection. During the opening of the nativity scene in the Crystal Hall, tributes were paid to volunteers. A ceremony was also held outside the town hall, where the square remained silent and dimly lit. A voice commemorated the victims, mentioning “the water that gives us life, and, a month ago, turned into mudslides that froze our blood.” It added that “this tragedy has not stolen our hope or the unity of Valencia’s people.” The solemn moment was followed by music from a conservatory choir.
“Star of solidarity”
Following the tribute, Mayor Maria José Catalá and local officials pressed the button to illuminate a 25-metre-high Christmas tree. Mayor Catalá said the tree symbolised the “Star of Solidarity,” intended to bring light and hope to the community while reinforcing solidarity. The lighting was accompanied by fireworks and special effects.
Public divided on Christmas kick-off
Reactions to the grand lighting were swift and divided. Many acknowledged the importance of the event for businesses, but victims of the DANA disaster labelled the mayor “insensitive.” They voiced frustration at not being included in the festivities. Critics argue Catalá’s focus is on attracting tourists, a crucial part of the local economy, while the city government insists it is aware of the hardships faced by victims.
The contrast between Valencia’s festive lights and the perceived inadequate support for affected areas has not gone unnoticed. While the government speaks of solidarity, many claim it has failed to provide real financial assistance and aid to devastated communities.